Listening today to the NewstalkZB discussion of youth vandalism (which relate to my recent post) and the Pike River mining incident (29 miners trapped in a complex and multi-faceted situation).
Yet again, we see that technology is neither good nor bad.
If it’s good things we’re aiming to do, technology aids and strengthens our efforts.Â If it is best to send in human rescuers (or sacrificial, courageous fathers), then what a blessing to have breathing apparatuses & other gear to help them.Â If it’s best to send in a robot instead (as was decided – controversially), then what a blessing to have such technology to even give us the choice (and even better if it is able to withstand watery conditions – which it unfortunately was not).
If it is bad things we’re aiming to do, technology aids and strengthens these efforts as well.Â If it is not good to send in a less-than-robust robot to do a human’s job, then what a distraction the whole idea turned out to be.Â If it is not good for every opinion to be broadcast, then what a pain to have a mechanism like talk-back radio.
One caller was grateful for the discretion of the police, who kept people from taking the situation into ‘their own hands’ – as if it wasn’t in human hands anyway?Â Humans are responsible for doing what they can.Â More technology gives us more ‘can do’ options (can-do doesn’t equal should-do.), but is there a point when we have too many options?Â More power, but too much power?Â Does it make us hesitate to act courageously, or make us too dependent on technology?
A parallel scenario was the months before and weeks after Thomas was born, two years ago.Â We found the ante-natal classes generally helpful, and were grateful that we live in a time/place where such things are freely available to all.Â But we also noted that the sheer amount of information can be at times suffocating.Â You are given so many options and told about so many scenarios to be prepared for.Â There is being prepared on one hand, and on the other being so aware of the 74,000 things that ‘could’ happen that you worry they ‘will’ happen.Â Other parents we talked to related to this.Â At some point, we all have to trust those that know – even if we don’t.